As Americans across the country gather to celebrate Independence Day, the spotlight turns to one of the nation’s most cherished culinary icons: the hot dog. Originating amidst the post-Civil War reconstruction era in the 1860s, this quintessentially American treat has deep roots on the bustling boardwalk of New York City’s Coney Island.
While Nathan’s Famous proudly claims the title of the “original” hot dog since 1916, history reveals a deeper story. Decades earlier, German immigrant Charles L Feltman introduced the concept of the hot dog to Coney Island in 1867. Feltman’s innovative twist on the German frankfurter quickly gained popularity, with his signature long bun making it a convenient beachside delight. Despite Feltman’s early success, it was Nathan Handwerker who, inspired by his time at Feltman’s, opened his own hot dog stand in 1916, undercutting Feltman’s prices and eventually building an international empire.
However, the legacy of Feltman’s was not lost to history. Revived by Coney Island historian Michael Quinn, Feltman’s hot dogs have made a triumphant return, offering a taste of nostalgia with premium beef, authentic spices, and a loyal following. Today, both Nathan’s and Feltman’s continue to thrive, each with their own devoted fan base and accolades.
Whether you prefer the historic allure of Feltman’s or the global reach of Nathan’s, the hot dog remains a symbol of American ingenuity and culinary tradition. As you fire up the grill this Fourth of July, consider the humble hot dog’s journey from a Coney Island boardwalk novelty to an international sensation, inviting all to savor a slice of American history with every bite.